| | |
1 | Soredia absent | 2 |
| Soredia present, situated on edge or underside of lobes | 1. candelaria |
2(1) | Thallus with narrow lobes, the apices up to 1 mm across | 3 |
| Thallus with wide lobes, the apices (0·5–)1–7 mm across | 4 |
3(2) | Thallus with finger-like, convex lobes spreading outwards beyond apothecia; on rock | 2. elegans |
| Thallus with finely divided lobe-ends often obscured by crowded apothecia; on bark and wood, rare on rock | 6. polycarpa |
4(2) | Lobes rounded at apices, scarcely indented; thallus of ± flat, regular rosettes | 5 |
| Lobes strap-shaped, deeply divided; thallus often irregular, hummock-forming, of overlapping lobes | 5. ectaneoides |
5(4) | Thallus isidiate; isidia irregularly globose-capitulate, continuous; apothecia peltate, urceolate to concave, with involute thalline exciple | 4. calcicola |
| Thallus not isidiate, but sometimes with flattened lobules (on damaged thalli); apothecia ± sessile, usually with raised thalline exciple | 3. parietina |